Rates are rising. Are Australia’s biggest bank shares still worth buying?

The last time Australia faced back-to-back interest rate rises, most investors were hoping the worst was behind them.

Not anymore.

The Reserve Bank of Australia has now raised the cash rate to 4.1%, following a hike in February, and all four major banks had tipped this move as a near certainty heading into today’s decision. That is two increases in a matter of months, reversing much of the easing cycle that played out through 2025. The catalyst is well-known: persistent inflation, a tight labour market, and an oil shock from the Middle East conflict that has complicated the RBA’s path back to target.

For shareholders in Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA), the question is what any of this actually means for one of the ASX’s most closely watched businesses.

The rate rise paradox

Higher interest rates are, in theory, good for banks. When the cash rate rises, lenders can reprice their loan books faster than their deposit costs, widening the net interest margin (NIM) — the spread between what a bank charges borrowers and what it pays savers. Commonwealth Bank’s NIM is already among the strongest of the major banks.

But there is a catch. That same rate rise squeezes the customers Commonwealth Bank relies on.

With the cash rate now at 4.1%, and potentially heading higher again in May if inflation data stays sticky, mortgage holders are absorbing real pressure. Each 25 basis point rise adds roughly $90 per month to repayments on a $600,000 loan. Two rises in 2026 alone adds $180 per month for millions of Australian households — many of whom bank with the big four.

The risk is not just sentiment; it is also credit quality. Higher rates for longer raise the probability of loan arrears climbing and some borrowers falling into difficulty. The RBA’s own forecasts project unemployment will rise gradually toward 4.6% by mid-2028 as tighter policy slows growth. That headwind does not hit immediately, but it builds.

What does the current valuation actually tell you?

Commonwealth Bank shares are currently trading around $176, which puts the price-to-earnings ratio at roughly 28 times. That is the highest valuation of the big four banks, and well above the long-run average for Australian banking stocks as a sector.

To put that in context: the trailing dividend yield sits at close to 2.9%, fully franked. The most recent interim dividend was $2.35 per share, paid in late March. For income-focused investors, the franking credits add meaningful value on a grossed-up basis. However, compared to where Commonwealth bank has historically yielded — and compared to peers like National Australia Bank Ltd (ASX: NAB) and Westpac Banking Corporation (ASX: WBC), which trade at lower multiples and higher yields — the income argument for buying Commonwealth Bank at current prices is relatively thin.

The premium has always been there, and it has always been justified to a degree. Commonwealth Bank’s H1 FY2026 cash net profit after tax came in at $5.45 billion, up 6% on the prior period. Return on equity remains among the highest in the sector. The brand, the scale, and the technology investment program are genuine competitive advantages that peers have not been able to replicate.

Yet, a premium valuation priced for near-perfection leaves limited room for error. If net interest margins normalise as competition for deposits intensifies, or if loan impairments tick up in a higher-for-longer rate environment, that 28 times multiple becomes harder to defend.

The Foolish takeaway

Commonwealth Bank is not a bad business. It is arguably one of the best-run banks in the world, and it has consistently rewarded long-term shareholders who held through noise and uncertainty.

The honest question in 2026 is whether the current price already reflects all of that quality, and then some. At 28 times earnings with a sub-3% yield, investors are paying a significant premium over peers for a franchise that, while exceptional, faces the same credit cycle headwinds as every other lender. That does not make the shares uninvestable. But for investors weighing up where to put new capital in a rising rate environment, the price being asked for Commonwealth Bank deserves careful thought.

The post Rates are rising. Are Australia’s biggest bank shares still worth buying? appeared first on The Motley Fool Australia.

More reading

• How are Australia’s biggest blue-chip stocks performing in 2026?
• Here’s what experts think will happen with the RBA interest rate this year
• Why the RBA could increase interest rates again in May
• CBA shares: 3 reasons to buy and 3 reasons to sell
• Forget CBA shares! Buy these ASX dividend shares instead for passive income

Motley Fool contributor Leigh Gant has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia’s parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.